ID card was supposed to make things easier (7 Days in Dubai)
I went to update my eGate card only to be told that they can’t use our UAE ID cards because they don’t have the machines to accept the cards.
I thought paying out all that money for ID cards was to help out with situations if you didn’t have your passport with you. What’s going on?
Two things of note here…
If “Confused, UAE” is typical, customers/users/stakeholders are beginning to expect interoperability as far as ID systems go.
The social media presence of the Emirates ID people is impressive. The Emirates ID Authority found this post a day after it went up and used the site’s comments section to offer assistance to the individual having problems. That’s pretty cool.
Twitter: @EmiratesID
UPDATE: 8 NOVEMBER 2012
The people at the Emirates ID Authority were kind enough to direct my attention to web resources explaining how Emiratis (citizens and residents) can add e-gate service to their Emirates ID for use at all UAE airports.
@securlinx Good morning, please be advised that you can activate the e-gate service on the Emirates ID card and use it .. Cont.
— Emirates ID (@EmiratesID) November 8, 2012
@securlinx over all UAE airports. Please find more about e-gate service on: bit.ly/Ssg4F4
— Emirates ID (@EmiratesID) November 8, 2012
They’re saying that the e-gates and the national ID systems are, in fact, interoperable.
The question, however, of why the holder of an Emirates ID must proactively link their ID to the e-gate system remains. So let’s take a look at what automatic recognition of every Emirates ID at e-gates would mean.
For all Emirates ID’s to work automatically and by default with all e-gates at all UAE airports with a high degree of security and accuracy, the UAE central ID database would have to either:
(1) be available to hardware (e-gates) located at all airports at all times (in order to compare information on the card with information in the database) or
(2) regularly update all e-gate hardware with copies of parts of the central database information (the parts relevant to travel) on all residents at all UAE airports.
There are actually some pretty good reasons you might not want to do either of these things, database security first and foremost among them. Regarding a national ID central database, a conservative approach to information sharing would yield an attitude that the least amount of information should be shared that still allows the desired service to be provided. Right now that seems to mean that only a small slice of information held by the Emirates ID Authority about a small slice of the population is shared to the e-gate system on an opt-in basis.
Like we occasionally say around here, ID management technology is a powerful tool. The management part is very important though. People — human managers and decision makers — give its use meaning. Perhaps one day ID information will be shared ubiquitously and securely to provide extremely high levels of citizen services without requiring much if any forethought from individuals. It looks like that’s the way the world is heading, however haltingly. But it’s also easy to see why a government, especially an early adopting one, would want to take a step by step approach toward getting there.
Of course, one could still quibble with other management decisions such as the fees or the extra bureaucratic step involved, but that’s a question of how, rather than why.
I’ll also repeat my earlier praise for the Emirates ID social media presence.
@EmiratesID (by our own experience) and @EmiratesID_Help (by all appearances) are both highly engaged and responsive ways for the public both inside and outside the UAE to learn more about and interact with the Emirates ID Authority.
UPDATE II: 11 NOVEMBER 2012
I’m afraid I was understood by @EmiratesID to be saying the opposite of what I meant as the update above prompted this response:
@securlinx Thank you for sharing your article & feedback with us. On the contrary to your view, there are a few who find this service…cont
— Emirates ID (@EmiratesID) November 11, 2012
@securlinx …useful and beneficial, considering that we are moving forward with our technology and offered services.
— Emirates ID (@EmiratesID) November 11, 2012
That’s not contrary to our view, at all. We take @EmiratesID at its word that “there are a few who find this service useful and beneficial…” In fact, I’m quite sure they’re being modest.
Of course, some complaints are inevitable with ID and airports. I don’t wish to elevate one person’s confusion as the issue. The interesting things about the 7 Days in Dubai piece that inspired this post are the questions it provokes about how high-tech ID systems work, why they work the way they do, and the importance of efforts to help and explain things to stakeholders.
For the e-gates to work in the way that “Confused, UAE” expected, database practices that many would consider unwise would have to be put into place. Given that the technology is new and that the UAE is an early adopter of a more high-tech approach to ID, it is important to strike a proper balance between convenience and service on the one hand and data security on the other. The Emirates ID Authority is by all appearances serious about striking that balance and possess the abilities to do so. It is therefore not surprising in the least that many (even the vast majority) of Emiratis find the technology and services offered by the Emirates ID Authority extremely useful and beneficial.
I am aware of no evidence that the EmiratesID Authority is “doing it wrong” and there is plenty of evidence that they are doing it right. That includes their responsiveness as an organization and I thank them for it.
[Edit: In the case that someone at EmiratesID (or anyone else for that matter) wants to respond more expansively than allowed by Twitter’s 140 character limit, I can be reached at blog@securlinx.com and would love to hear from you.]
